Addressing the Dilemma: Is it Better to Resurface or Replace Concrete?

Deciphering the Resurfacing Vs Replacement Conundrum

Concrete’s durability doesn’t render it invincible. Over time, wear and tear can leave its mark, prompting the need for restoration. In such scenarios, the quandary of whether to resurface or replace the concrete often emerges. Herein, a careful examination of your situation will yield the optimal solution.

Concrete Resurfacing: Unveiling the Ins and Outs

Concrete resurfacing involves applying a thin layer of a cement-based overlay onto existing concrete, effectively concealing cracks, discolouration, or surface degradation. This approach is commonly employed in various Auckland suburbs, from the steep inclines of Mt. Eden to the bustling streets of Northcote on the North Shore.

In terms of pricing, concrete resurfacing offers a cost-effective solution, with prices starting from approximately $50 per square metre in the Auckland market. Different finishes are available, allowing for customisation according to aesthetic preferences and the specific needs of the area.

Concrete Replacement: The Whole Nine Yards

In stark contrast, concrete replacement implies the removal of the existing concrete and installation of a new surface. This solution is often reserved for severely damaged concrete or where structural integrity is in question. If you are in an older suburb such as Herne Bay, replacement might be a more common occurrence given the age of the infrastructures.

As expected, the price tag for concrete replacement is substantially higher, typically beginning at $100 per square metre, and can escalate based on the complexity of the project.

Adhering to Auckland’s Health and Safety Standards

Regardless of the approach, concrete work must comply with the WorkSafe New Zealand guidelines, ensuring safety throughout the process. Contractors adhere to these standards, incorporating them into their cost estimates and work timelines.

Auckland Council Bylaws: Affecting Your Choice

Auckland Council bylaws can also factor into the resurfacing vs replacement decision. For example, in the Manukau Ward, any extensive driveway work might require consent if it impacts the kerb or footpath. In such scenarios, replacement might require a lengthier approval process and additional costs. In contrast, in Albert-Eden-Roskill Ward, bylaws pertaining to noise control could influence the timeline of your project.

Environmental Considerations: Resurface or Replace?

From an environmental standpoint, resurfacing often gets the nod. As this process utilises the existing concrete as a base, it significantly reduces the amount of waste and the carbon footprint associated with producing new concrete. For Aucklanders aiming to go green, resurfacing is a sustainable option.

Key Takeaways

  • The choice between resurfacing and replacing concrete hinges on the condition of your concrete and the costs involved.
  • Complying with health and safety guidelines and Auckland Council bylaws can impact your decision.
  • Resurfacing is a more eco-friendly option compared to concrete replacement.

FAQ

Is resurfacing a suitable option for all types of concrete damage? While resurfacing is effective for minor cracks and discolouration, it may not be adequate for significant structural damage. Always consult with a concrete resurfacing contractor to determine the best course of action.

Does concrete resurfacing last as long as new concrete? Although resurfacing may not last as long as new concrete, with proper care and maintenance, it can prolong the life of your concrete by several years.

Can I resurface the concrete myself? While DIY resurfacing is possible, professional concrete resurfacing ensures that the job is done right, delivering a high-quality finish and lasting results.